The two main British makers have both had a
stab, Timpo (right) went with one
tool, manufacturing in two colours and then gluing opposite-colour pieces to
each other for a choice of two, otherwise identical boxes!
Britains (left) had three, the Herald one in the middle we'll return to in a
second, there was a larger one in the later years (which is a near-copy of
their (or T&B's (?)) earlier
hollow/slush-cast one I think?) and the semi-flat or relief 'stage scenery' one
from late Herald [Hong Kong]'s windowed,
long-box sets.
Returning to the earlier Herald version; it gave rise to a family
of near-identical, but different boxes, with here from the left; Herald, Kentoy, Cavendish, and
two unknown's either of which may (or may not) be Trojan, UNA or VP, or even Speedwell . . . or someone else entirely?
Rather than try to explain all the
differences, it's easier to present them as a table for those whose levels of
geekiness equal mine to pore-over and compare with the above images!
I will waffle over the marks though! (1) is
obviously the Herald design, (2) is
the Kentoys version, which - frankly
- is the [slightly] better design, it's a tad 'cleaner', more symmetrical and
better etched than the Herald
version. (3) is the Cavendish
version, it's clearly had an attempt at removing the 'KENTOY' first line,
although it remains readable if you do that 'turning-it in the light' thing!
I think (4) is the one credited to UNA in the Plastic Warrior 'special' of
2009, it's also seen in grey (as a copy) in the Kentoys special of the same year; it has a heavier gable/roof edge?
Trojan don't have one listed (so
far!), neither do VP (yet), but then there is (5) waiting for an ascribing too!
Also; given the similarities between the Herald and Kentoy ones, might Gemodels'
Musgrave be in there somewhere, I had presumed Norman Tooth for both similar
designs? Although there's no larger ex-Herald
one in the new Speedwell 'special'
(post due . . . overdue!), one has to consider them for the unknown '5' above
along with the other possible 'names'?
I seem to have crammed the rest into one
collage, but that's how the cookie crumbled, so that's how it is and what we
have to work with!
Image A has
the 'foreigners', with Афина (Athena) from Greece at 1, and Reisler's equally common Danish box at
2, both have been sold as tourist keepsakes for decades and are just as common
as Britains' examples. 3 is from Hong
Kong and must be from larger playsets? The Riesler
has an incorrect flag, actually taken from a Guards musician!
Image B
shows - on the right (2) what I'm pretty sure is Crescent's wooden one which ran alongside their figures through
both the hollow-cast and plastic years, but I have a half-an-inkling the heavy
steel 'tin-plate' one is Crescent
too? But I stand to be corrected by someone who does know! Chris Smith is to be
thanked for sending the wooden one to the Blog the other day.
Image C is
not that clear, I used to think they were die-cast (and probably Wardie/Mastermodels; they're quite
small?), but they may be a hardish whitemetal ('lead') slush-cast, which would
open the field of possible makers considerably?
Image D has
the diminutive Speedwell box on the
right and an unknown wooden giant (also from Chris Smith - thanks again Chris)
on the left, the chevron stripes are a bit 'Euro' looking and I suspect a reasonably
modern, probably infant's wooden castle or building-blocks type set?
All of them in size-order with the two
'middle' ends duplicated and the addition of the little Airfix one from the Guards
Colour Party on the far end of the last line-up. The Athena one should have a sentry glued to it - like the Reisler one
Favorite? I quite like the little
may-not-be-Mastermodels
may-not-be-diecsat, I'm 'pleased' with the Speedwell
from the big purchase, but I don't think you can beat the octagonal Reisler with its pointy, fairy-tale roof
and Royal-cipher transfer if you are thinking of starting a collection of these.
Now, it was the arrival of the two
wooden-ones from Chris that pre-empted this post, the two (now three) tubs had
been here for some time waiting for a post's photo-shoot, but also waiting to
have the sentry-boxes here sorted into them, which may not have happened? I
can't remember!
It doesn't really matter, but there may be
a creamy- or dirty-white version of the yellow Hong Kong one somewhere, and
possibly a Starlux one (another
common one for tourism reasons) although we have seen the small-scale version
here at Small Scale World in the
past. Also missing is the Hong Kong [and/for] Cavendish one, with its plinth, but that's also been on the Blog,
recently!
I have another small-scale lead one
somewhere, which featured with a penguin and some Danish Guards years ago,
possibly on HäT as a
long-gone Imagshack-upload, but I'm not sure where they've ended-up . . .
they're here somewhere; along with a flat one.
There are plenty of cheapie-kahki types
from rack-toy playsets, but they are another thing altogether, there's a few
small-scale card ones kicking around in the 'paper' crate I think and I used to
have the mail-away with 'stars' 1:12th Action
Man one, which differed in design from the retail one, both were heavy,
mounting-card.
Also Fujimi,
Hasegawa and Nitto produced small ones with check-point kits as did Airfix in 1:32, in fact I think I have
one somewhere? I seem to recall a bag of grey polystyrene bits (no bridge?)
came in at some point - possibly from Jim?
So, we'll have to return to them sooner
rather than later! In the meantime, thanks to Chris for triggering this post.
Hello Hugh, nice post. Had a lot of the green wooden ones recently. Not sure on origin of the white one either. My favourite is a jean one, white plastic with red chevrons cleverly made in two parts, the white outer has the chevron holes in it then theres a red insert with a base which fits inside. Was a chunky 60mm scale and for some reason i sold on, regretting that now. Cheers Chris
ReplyDeleteHi Chris - Thanks for the two above, I don't know the Jean one (I'll find it!), but it sounds similar to their Tee-Pee/Tipi, which is both different to everyone else's, while at the same time a bit juvenile?
ReplyDeleteCheers
H